LilFish_JWQueen(:":dd20tt65 said:
Ok maybe your thinking depth????..by saying three fingered drop from the top of the back to the top of his hip.....Im talking about how smooth the rabbit is when you feel it like a judge would...by taking your cupped hand and feeling from the shoulders to rump...If it catches at the hip or you feel a bump at the hip, A judge would call that hippy or catchy or catchy at the hip.
Im not saying hes MAJORLY hippy but from what i see he is. I mean it is a pal so its not that big of a deal..but im not gona go easy on the breed because of that cause I would like to see a breed like this improve and get more popular.
But besides everyone has an opinion and its like judges..every show is different cause every judge has their own opinion.
The term "hippy" as it pertains to just about any commercial breed basically means that their hips sit higher than they should, that is almost always going to be accompanied by a flat spot on the shoulder, and yes it also pertains to depth at the loin (or the lack thereof).
With most commercial breeds, a breeder wants to see a good rise between where the top of the hip bone stops and where the top of the back is. A common way of measuring it is by placing the edge of your pinky finger on the top of the hip and counting the number of fingers which fit between the top of the hip and the top of the loin. That rise and depth (along with how the rabbit finishes in the hindquarters, where the crest or top of the arch over their back occurs, and how quickly their flesh at the shoulder rises off the base of the ears) goes a long way toward scoring body type, which is huge in any breed, but most especially with a commercial breed. And for a Palomino, yes, it is a VERY big deal in terms of how they're ultimately scored not only for BOB/BOS, but for BIS as well.
Looking at Japheth's photo, I can see very noticeable strengths over Shem. One of which is the depth and rise at the loin, which as he fully develops may easily be 4 fingers depth and that is serious/phenomenal rise. Another is how he finishes into his lower hindquarter. Not that Shem is a bad animal, he'll probably develop well as time goes along, but Japheth is just finished and developed better. Neither one of us is able to feel out that rabbit as you're describing, but what you're stating as far as what you're seeing defines what is wrong with judging today IMHO. It's almost like most judges I've encountered in the past year go out of their way to demonstrate that they don't know the first thing about how to judge a commercial breed. You simply cannot judge them by the same standard as you would apply to any fancy breed you may wish to name, and you're shortchanging not only the rabbit and its owner, but also the breed as they go up for BIS later on in the show by judging them in such a way.
I don't mean any of this in a mean-spirited way, but here's what you owe it to yourself to do. Hang around the table when Californians, Palominos, New Zealands, Satins and any of a number of other commercial breeds are being judged, and listen to the judge's comments. Ask a few of the more reputable breeders what they tend to look for when they select their animals. Compare that to what the breeds' printed standards say, and you'll get your answer of what an animal is supposed to look like. And I'd bet a dollar to a dozen donuts that the judges are wrong in the way they place them as least as often as they're right, if not more so. Your garden variety judge simply doesn't comprehend what a commercial breed should look like today.